Broadening the Tax Base  Ensuring Our Future Prosperity  What's the Best Option for Hong Kong?
繁體 簡体  
Consultation Document & Leaflets
Interim Report
Final Report
Compendium of Written Submissions
Advisory Committee's Report(2002)
Other Options for Broadening Tax Base
Press Releases & Speeches
Related Documents
Links
     
  Frequently Asked Questions  
 

FAQ on Goods and Services Tax (GST)

A. The Nature and Framework of GST

Q1 GST and Retail Sales Tax ("RST") are both consumption taxes. What are their differences?
Q2 As individual consumption would also fluctuate with economic ups and downs, how can GST produce more stable revenue?
Q3 Would the introduction of GST be in breach of the Basic Law?
Q4 Are all goods and services chargeable to GST?
Q5 What is "input tax"? What is "output tax"?
Q6 How is GST collected?
Q7 Assuming a 5% GST rate and tax is charged at each stage of the production and distribution chain, would the tax finally paid by end consumers be more than 5%?
Q8 Should basic necessities like food, medical services and education be excluded from GST?
Q9 What is the definition of GST registration threshold? Is the threshold based on annual turnover or profits? Are those businesses below the registration threshold not subject to GST?
Q10 Why is the proposed registration threshold set at an annual turnover of $5 million? Would large businesses split their turnover to avoid registration?
Q11 What would be the compliance costs for registered businesses?
Q12 For small and medium-sized businesses not registered for GST, what would be the impact of GST on their costs?
Q13 Would GST lead to "tax-on-tax", i.e. double taxation?
Q14 Would GST complicate administrative procedures for businesses?
Q15 Why is it proposed that the duty rates on liquor, petrol, diesel, aircraft fuel and methyl alcohol be lowered accordingly upon the introduction of GST?
Q16 What is the rationale for not imposing GST on residential property purchase?
Q17 The estimated administrative cost of collecting GST is $500 million. Is this estimate on the low side?
Q18 Why is the GST rate assumed to be 5%? Are there any guarantees that the rate would not change in the future?
Q19 Overseas experience shows that after the introduction of GST, GST rates always increase. Does the Legislative Council have the power to reject the Government's proposal to increase the GST rate?

B. Compensation Package

Q20 What is the definition of the terms "non-CSSA low-income households" and "non-taxpaying lower-middle-income households" used in the Consultation Document?
Q21 How can we identify the Group 2 households referred to in the Consultation Document? Does the Government have any ideas regarding the eligibility criteria for assessing such households to grant the direct cash GST allowance?
Q22 In the proposal, Group 2 households (i.e. households with a monthly income below $11,000) would be provided with direct cash allowance of $2,000 a year. Would the amount of allowance be too small?
Q23 Has the Government considered that many low-income households could not fully avail themselves of the benefits from the annual GST credit of $3,000 against Rates and the annual GST credit of $500 against water and sewage charges? In that case, would the proposed relief measures still be adequate for these households?
Q24 The offset package is designed on the basis of households and could not address individual needs. Should it be formulated on the basis of individuals and subject to annual adjustment?
Q25 Retirees have not expected that GST would be included in their living expenses while in retirement. How is the Government going to help them?
Q26 Please explain the use of the surplus fund of $20 billion from GST. How would the Government return this surplus fund from GST to the public?

C. Impact on Individual Industries

Education

Q27 Should school education be exempted from GST?
Q28 It would be contrary to the principle of nurturing talent through education if school fees were not exempt from GST. How can the burden of GST on parents and non-profit-making schools be alleviated?

Charities

Q29 How would GST apply to charities?

Tourism and Hospitality

Q30 Would GST have any impact on Hong Kong's tourism?
Q31 Why is the threshold for tourist refunds set at HK$1,500? Is it too high? What are the anticipated impacts on tourism?
Q32 The Government proposes that the threshold for tourist refunds be set at $1,500. Could the value of goods purchased from different shops be aggregated to meet the threshold level?
Q33 With regard to the Tourist Refund Scheme, the Consultation Document proposes the implementation of the "sealed bag" system and there are plans to outsource the refund process. Does this mean that the amount of refund would decrease significantly as the administrative costs of the scheme would be borne by the tourists?
Q34 How would Customs at various control points ensure that GST is paid on goods that exceed the threshold allowance and are brought in by individual incoming travellers?

Retail Industry

Q35 Would the introduction of GST encourage the public to spend in the Mainland, thus dampening our retail industry?
Q36 Would there be a requirement to indicate in the listed prices the total amount of GST to be collected on goods and services?
Q37 Would GST eat into business profits?
Q38 Would the introduction of GST have any impact on Hong Kong's retail industry?

Real Property

Q39 If a GST registrant who purchases or rents commercial premises could reclaim the GST he paid, then, why wouldn't the Government simply exempt or zero rate commercial premises?

Import/Export Trade

Q40 Would exports and re-exports be chargeable to GST?
Q41 Does the proposed GST framework provide any facilitating measures for importers, exporters and re-exporters?
Q42 Would the introduction of GST increase the demand for storage of imported goods in bonded warehouses by importers?

Financial services

Q43 Would share trading transactions, such as stock brokerage commissions, not be chargeable to GST?
Q44 Does insurance fall within the scope of "financial supplies"? Since a part of life insurance is savings in nature, would life insurance also be chargeable to GST?
Q45 Would interest on bank deposits also be chargeable to GST?

Manufacturing industry

Q46 Would the cost of raw materials increase as a result of GST introduction?
Q47 How would GST impact on those industries that require further processing to be done in Hong Kong?
Q48 Many local manufacturers have relocated their production lines to the Mainland. If manufacturers have to pay GST for every importation of semi-manufactured goods, the costs of manufacturing would increase, and this might drive some manufacturers away from Hong Kong, which runs counter to the intent of CEPA. How would the Government handle this problem?

D. Impact on the Community

Q49 Would the GST increase the financial burden of non-CSSA low-income households and drive up the number of CSSA application?
Q50 The proposed GST is regressive in nature and unfair to the low-income people. Would this proposal rob the poor for the rich and widen the wealth gap further?
Q51 Why is the rise in the inflation rate as a result of GST expected to be only 3% after the introduction of a 5% GST?
Q52 With the substantial increase in government revenue after the introduction of GST, would there be a significant increase in expenditure? Would it contribute to a 'Big Government'? How to ensure that the Government would maintain a tight control on expenditure?
Q53 Would our competitiveness be undermined by the introduction of GST?
Q54 Would the introduction of GST complicate our simple and low-rate tax system?